Childrens Writers Chat 8-28-01

Subject: Childrens Writers Chat - reviews

Author: Writerbabe

Uploaded By: JOANWRITE

Date: 8/30/2001

File: CWC8-28-01.log (17035 bytes)

Estimated Download Time (17541 baud): < 1 minute

Download Count: 15

Equipment: whatever got you here

Needs: whatever can read a text file

Childrens Writers Chat 8-28-01

Discussion topic: Reviews

TTuesdays

9 p.m. ET (6 p.m. PT), Writers Workshop

Children's Writers chat - writers and illustrators of children's books meet for specific topics and special guest speakers, moderated by HOST WRTR WBABE & HOST WRTR CGaley, with HOST WRTR sUe & HOST WRTR Neely (Greeters).

****disinfected using Virex 6.0****

<HTML>Children's Writers' Workshop 8-28-01

Discussion topic: Reviews

WriterBabe: Okay, folks, we're open for questions now.

WriterBabe: How can we get our books reviewed in more media and featured in

RoxyanneY: ?

WriterBabe: features? GA

KellyMilnerH: Talk to EVERYONE about your book.

OtterBabe3: ?

KellyMilnerH: Carry a copy with you EVERYWHERE.

KellyMilnerH: Show it to anyone who will look.

LYPHIS: ?

KellyMilnerH: You never know who will hear you. That's how a friend of a

friend tells the feature editor.

KellyMilnerH: That's how I get some books. I listen. I ask. Don't be shy.

And look at yourself differently

KellyMilnerH: Ask yourself why you wrote the book and see if there is a

great feature in the reason.

KellyMilnerH: I raised baby chickens...that made my story behind the story

on BABY CHICKEN great for

KellyMilnerH: agricultural magazines. And chicken people buy chicken books.

KellyMilnerH: GA

WriterBabe: Hmm, I think I'd like to get a lackey to carry around my book.

Easier on the back. LOL

WriterBabe: Roxy, you're first.

RoxyanneY: Shoot, that's what I was going to ask - can we send reviewers

copies of our books if we

RoxyanneY: don't have a relationship with them, or is that considered tacky

or overkill, or just not a

RoxyanneY: good idea because of the expense involved -- the publisher should

be the one sending out the

RoxyanneY: books, yes? GA

KellyMilnerH: Roxy, some reviewers hate it, because they hate letting people

down. But if you have an

KellyMilnerH: extra review copy and you meet this interesting freelancer at

a writer's conference, send

KellyMilnerH: her a copy...with a note saying it was nice meeting. Again,

that will put your book in her

KellyMilnerH: mind. If something comes up, and she's any good, she'll

remember.

KellyMilnerH: But don't take it personally if it takes a while. GA

KellyMilnerH: Again, it's about relationship. GA

WriterBabe: Otter, your turn.

OtterBabe3: Hi Kel! What about reviews in other media? Features on TV, etc?

Also do you ever tap into

OtterBabe3: popular sources? Wouldn't it be great for Oprah to feature

children's books? ga

KellyMilnerH: Me personally? I don't do TV work. But a lot of good PR people

do.

KellyMilnerH: Kelly Grunther was the head of Random House Children's

publicity for nearly 9 years.

KellyMilnerH: She's freelance now and pitches TV regularly.

KellyMilnerH: But if you really want to get on Oprah, start local.

KellyMilnerH: The odds are good, if you get good local TV, then good state

TV, then good press, you can

KellyMilnerH: better your odds of being SEEN by Oprah or Good Morning

America.

KellyMilnerH: Start local, move up. GA

WriterBabe: Lyph, go ahead.

LYPHIS: How does one become a reviewer?

KellyMilnerH: LYPHIS, as silly as it sounds, you ask.

WriterBabe: (Queue's empty, folks)

KellyMilnerH: Not so different form the advice I just offered on TV. Start

small, free papers, local

LYPHIS: ?

KellyMilnerH: parenting sheets, then move up. Do a few for free, that's what

I did. In fact, I started

KellyMilnerH: online.

KellyMilnerH: GA

WriterBabe: Continue, Lyph.

LYPHIS: What should a review have to get published and influence people?

KellyMilnerH: Reviewer?

OtterBabe3: ?

LYPHIS: yes,

MudderGG: ?

KellyMilnerH: LYPHIS, if you're just gettting started, study the formats and

mirror them.

LYPHIS: in the review... is there some key to writing a great review?

KellyMilnerH: Make your desires known to the editors. Be a LITTLE pushy, but

not too pushy.

KellyMilnerH: Key to writing a great review is to write what your editor

wants...

KellyMilnerH: follow THEIR formats. And don't forget what makes a truly

great book.

KellyMilnerH: It's not just a famous author. There are some remarkable books

by new authors too.

KellyMilnerH: GA

WriterBabe: Otter, fire away.

OtterBabe3: I purchase books online and love having access to reviews

through the vendor I use. Is there

OtterBabe3: any way to access sources such as Baker & Taylor, etc. to get

them to feature your books? ga

KellyMilnerH: Yes...and again, it's about relationship.

RoxyanneY: ?

KellyMilnerH: It's not EASY, but if you get to BookExpo, seek out the PR

reps from Baker & Taylor, B&N.

KellyMilnerH: Introduce yourself, talk for a few minutes, hand them a copy

of your latest book or flyer.

KellyMilnerH: RELATIONSHIP.

KellyMilnerH: It might not get THAT book reviewed, but assuming you're in it

for the long haul, it will

KellyMilnerH: make them say, "Wow, look, another book by that woman at Book

Expo," the next time your name

KellyMilnerH: floats up.

KellyMilnerH: GA

WriterBabe: Mudder, you're next.

MudderGG: After a brand new writer sells his first book, would the hiring of

a PR person help to get

MudderGG: book reviewed? ga

KellyMilnerH: You want to know what got me 34 reviews for my first picture

book?

KellyMilnerH: The fact that I wrote reviews.

KellyMilnerH: RELATIONSHIP.

KellyMilnerH: Am I repeating that word?

KellyMilnerH: RELATIONSHIP.

KellyMilnerH: Yes, you can hire a PR person to advise you, and some of them

are wonderful.

KellyMilnerH: But if you can't afford one, there is SO much you can do on

your own.

KellyMilnerH: And you dont' have to be a cheerleader by nature to pull it

off.

KellyMilnerH: So yeah, they can help, but it doesn't have to go that way. GA

WriterBabe: Roxy, your turn.

RoxyanneY: What if a writer or illustrator gets a really horrible review

that they feel is undeserved.

RoxyanneY: Do they have any kind of recourse? GA

KellyMilnerH: Any recourse you attempt will make you look worse.

KellyMilnerH: That's a sad fact, but true.

RoxyanneY: So it's just out there, good or bad?

KellyMilnerH: I mean, if you argue or write a letter to the editor...unless

you're Chris Crutcher or Bruce

KellyMilnerH: Coville, I mean.

KellyMilnerH: Roxy, you can seek out opposing reviews from other sources.

KellyMilnerH: And you can remember, that reviews are subjective. Chicago

Tribune LOVED my picture book.

KellyMilnerH: SLJ said it was clunky. Go figure.

KellyMilnerH: GA

WriterBabe: Kel, are there any particular reviewers you admire? If so,

which--and why? GA

WriterBabe: (Queue's empty, folks)

KellyMilnerH: I really admire the reviewer for the Chicago Tribune, and of

course her name escapes me now.

KellyMilnerH: Mary...children's reviewer.

KellyMilnerH: She's an academic, a university expert on children's

literature.

KellyMilnerH: And I really admire Teri Leseire, the ALAN president, and I'm

misspelling HER name.

OtterBabe3: ?

KellyMilnerH: I think Stephanie Zvirin at Booklist is great, but she took

the star from Chris Crutcher's

KellyMilnerH: WHALE TALK review I wrote, which didn't please me.

KellyMilnerH: GA

WriterBabe: Why did she do that? And how do books get starred reviews

anyway? GA

KellyMilnerH: The reviewers suggest it...the editorial committee reviews the

suggestion.

KellyMilnerH: s

KellyMilnerH: WHALE TALK was supposed to have a starred review...they

decided against it.

KellyMilnerH: Changed my review a bit to reflect that.

KellyMilnerH: GA

RoxyanneY: ?

WriterBabe: Otter, go ahead.

OtterBabe3: As a reviewer, do you compare a writer's new book with others

she has written? Is this

KellyMilnerH: Because I've been doing this a while, I tend to have a pretty

good memory for previous title

OtterBabe3: important to your reviews?

OtterBabe3: ga

KellyMilnerH: But unless it's a series, no, it's not important. Sorry,

didn't mean to step on you.

KellyMilnerH: I will reference another book if I LOVED it. Can't hurt to

remind people of THAT book when I

KellyMilnerH: hope they'll take notice of THIS book.

KellyMilnerH: And when I write a great review, I want people to fall in love

with the book the way I did.

KellyMilnerH: GA

WriterBabe: Roxy, your turn.

RoxyanneY: Do you have any tips on interpreting book reviews? I mean, does a

starred review in

RoxyanneY: the Chicago Tribune mean the same thing as a starred review in

Kirkus? And what are

RoxyanneY: some of the buzz words that we see that might really mean

something else? GA

KellyMilnerH: Well, the Chicago Tribune's circulation isn't what Kirkus's

might be, in terms of book buyer

KellyMilnerH: But people do pay attention to certain reviews.

KellyMilnerH: Even the Denver Post can be powerful. I wrote a review of an

adult writer's latest book.

KellyMilnerH: She wound up the top seller in Denver the next week.

KellyMilnerH: And when you hit number one in a city, OTHER cities say, "Hey,

what's that buzz about?"

KellyMilnerH: GA

Neely f: <><><> 15 MINUTE WARNING <><<><>

RoxyanneY: ?

WriterBabe: Continue, Roxy.

RoxyanneY: Have you had reviews picked up by other papers from something

like that? Reprints?

KellyMilnerH: Good question.

KellyMilnerH: I've been asked to pitch a syndicated YA review column to

Copely.

Whisman RD: ?

KellyMilnerH: And a lot of what I have written for big newspapers get picked

up by their sister papers.

KellyMilnerH: Knight Ridder, etc.

KellyMilnerH: But what I try to do is write special features for each paper.

KellyMilnerH: For example, I wrote a LOT about Chris Crutcher in April.

KellyMilnerH: He hadn't had a book out in six years...people were hungry.

KellyMilnerH: But I wrote six DIFFERENT features...very different.

KellyMilnerH: So he got press, I got to pitch a book I loved, and all my

editors were happy. GA

WriterBabe: Whisman, you're next.

Whisman RD: do you often choose NOT to review a particular book?ga

KellyMilnerH: Not very often, no Whisman. Because for the most part, I can

find something magic in every

KellyMilnerH: book.

RoxyanneY: ?

KellyMilnerH: If they get to Booklist, and out to reviewers, they've already

made the first cut.

KellyMilnerH: That's another thing Roxy should remember. Even a bad review

means you're better than BAD.

KellyMilnerH: GA

WriterBabe: Kel, what do you think of the numerical rating system that

several publications use? GA

KellyMilnerH: I don't like it. I think it's WAY to misleading, Marilyn.

KellyMilnerH: Books are subjective by nature and design.

KellyMilnerH: And god bless them for being so. I think numerical systems

discount unnecessarily.

KellyMilnerH: GA

WriterBabe: Roxy, fire away.

RoxyanneY: What kind of feedback have you gotten from authors of the books

you've reviewed? Any thank

RoxyanneY: you notes? Dinner invitations? Flowers? GA

KellyMilnerH: Once in a while, yeah. I'll get flowers I didn't expect or a

nice note. Once I got a note

KellyMilnerH: telling me I was going to hell. I think maybe I liked that one

best.

KellyMilnerH: Chris always says if you piss off the right people, you're

doing something right.

KellyMilnerH: GA

WriterBabe: I once called a reviewer I know to thank her for a good review

and she told me never to do

WriterBabe: that.

RoxyanneY: (save me a seat :)

WriterBabe: Would that have been bad form with you, Kel? GA

KellyMilnerH: Nah. That's assuming a reviewer can't be objective.

KellyMilnerH: At this point, I know about 50% of working writers.

KellyMilnerH: I've written about SO MANY PEOPLE>

KellyMilnerH: If I can't write about people I know, I'm up a creek.

KellyMilnerH: I guess some people are insecure about what people will think.

KellyMilnerH: But I write about books I love. That isn't influenced by a

nice note.

KellyMilnerH: My LIFE is positively influenece by nice notes.

KellyMilnerH: GA

WriterBabe: I thought she was being rather uptight, frankly. She was my

neighbor!

KellyMilnerH: I think some people take themselves a LITTLE too seriously.

KellyMilnerH: GA

WriterBabe: What advice can you give us for dealing with reviews, both good

and bad? GA

KellyMilnerH: Chris once told me you can't take any review TOO seriously.

KellyMilnerH: The great ones cancel out the bad ones.

KellyMilnerH: And I think that's good advice. Then again, I've seen him get

loopy over a great review too.

OrganizedChaos06: Wow, what a large crowd

KellyMilnerH: Still, it's good advice. Remember reviewers are ONLY human.

KellyMilnerH: What they think is ONLY what they think.

KellyMilnerH: Ultimately, you'll find your KIND...and they'll keep buying

your books.

KellyMilnerH: RELATIONSHIP...have I said that yet? GA

WriterBabe: (Some don't seem human, Kel. :->)

KellyMilnerH: LOL...some have DEvolved, Marilyn.

Neely f: ^*^*^*^* 5 MINUTE WARNING ^*^**^^*

KellyMilnerH: GA

KellyMilnerH: One other thing...

WriterBabe: Any more questions, folks?

KellyMilnerH: My advise is to write YOUR book...your passion.

KellyMilnerH: Don't WORRY what any reviewer might say. If you're true to

yourself, again, your work will

KellyMilnerH: find it's way.

KellyMilnerH: GA

WriterBabe: Always good advice!

WriterBabe: Any more questions?

WriterBabe: I guess not.

KellyMilnerH: This reminds me of a conference I did in Albany.

KellyMilnerH: LOL

KellyMilnerH: Me and three librarians.

KellyMilnerH: LOL

WriterBabe: Kelly, thank you so much for a truly excellent chat.

Whisman RD: Thanks, Kelly! And goodnight.

MudderGG: My review for this chat session is 4 Stars.

KellyMilnerH: Thank you Marilyn, it was great fun as always.

RoxyanneY: This was really informative. Thank you, Kelly!

LYPHIS: Tha

KellyMilnerH: Mudder, thanks.

KellyMilnerH: Hope so Roxy.

Pete n Gun: Thanks Kelly.

RoxyanneY: Mudder, you crack me up.

Tem292: Yes, thanks Kelly

WriterBabe: Whoohoo! Mudder ranks high!

LYPHIS: Thanks Kelly and Marilyn and all - enlightening, very.

KellyMilnerH: Now I get to host Aldo Alvarez in the WCEvents Coliseum.

OtterBabe3: Thanks Kelly! Great advice and insight!

ShermanTL: Thanks, Kelly!

BOEDEN: Thank you Kelly for the generous information. Very interesting.

See you again soon!

KellyMilnerH: I'm glad you all enjoyed it.

KellyMilnerH: Otter, didn't I review you once?

MudderGG: <:O)))

BOEDEN: Thank you Marilyn, Donna, Chuck & Joan. Terrific job as always.

WriterBabe: He's a good guy, Kel.

KellyMilnerH: For Kids Reads?

CGaley: G'night!

Tem292: I missed most of it, but what I got was something about how good it

is to have a lot of

Tem292: relationships?!!

WriterBabe: Next week, Open Chat with Chuck, Donna, Sue. I'm going on

vacation.

CGaley: See all of you next week... OPEN CHAT

KellyMilnerH: Tem, email me if you have questions.

OtterBabe3: Nope, not there yet Kel. We chat from time to time. :-)

MudderGG: Tem tee hee

KellyMilnerH: Ah, must be a premonition, huh Otter?

KellyMilnerH: <g>

WriterBabe: Two weeks from tonight, I'll be back and our guest will be Susan

Rich, Lemony Snicket's

WriterBabe: editor at HarperCollins.

WriterBabe: See you then.

BOEDEN: Happy writing everyone. Nighty night. See you on the books lists!

KellyMilnerH: YAY, I love Lemony Snicket.

OtterBabe3: I can only hope Kel! Thanks!

WriterBabe: Night!

KellyMilnerH: See ya then Marilyn.

Neely f: Well folks, That's about it for this balmy summer night.

RoxyanneY: 'night, all

KellyMilnerH: If anyone knows AD Alvarez, come on over to the Coliseum,

WCEvents.

KellyMilnerH: Night

Neely f: Ad's a friend.

END</HTML>

Search This Blog

Strange Texts

Childrens Writers Chat 8-28-01

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

WHAT THE WATCH TOWER BIBLE AND TRACT SOCIETY OF PENNSYLVANIA HAD TO SAY ABOUT WHAT WERE SUPPOSED TO HAVE HAPPENED in 1874

Uninterruptable Power Source (UPS) FAQ

Blade Runner FAQ