Children's Writers Chat 11-14-00 Guest: Patty Campbell, reviewer/feature writer of YAs

Subject: Childrens Writers Chat-PCampbell

Author: writerbabe

Uploaded By: JOANWRITE

Date: 11/28/2000

File: CWC 11-14-00.log (15394 bytes)

Estimated Download Time (17541 baud): < 1 minute

Download Count: 13

Equipment: whatever got you here

Needs: whatever can read a text file

Children's Writers Chat 11-14-00

Guest: Patty Campbell, reviewer/feature writer of YAs

Tuesdays

9 p.m. ET (6 p.m. PT), Writers Workshop

Children's Writers chat - writers and illustrators of children's books meet for specific topics and special guest speakers, moderated by HOST WRTR WBABE & HOST WRTR CGaley, with HOST WRTR sUe & HOST WRTR Neely (Greeters).

****disinfected using Disinfectant 3.7.1****

<HTML>Children's Writers Chat 11-14-00

Guest: Patty Campbell, reviewer/feature writer of YAs

WriterBabe: We're going into protocol now.

WriterBabe: That means when it's time for audience participation, type ? for

a question,

WriterBabe: ! for a comment, and wait your turn in the queue to be called

on.

WriterBabe: Type GA for Go Ahead (guests, too) when you've finished

speaking.

WriterBabe: My co-host Chuck Galey may butt in at will.

CGaley: (Hi!)

WriterBabe: Wave, Chuck!

CGaley: (waving!)

WriterBabe: Tonight I'm so pleased to welcome a critic, writer, librarian,

brainiac I greatly admire:

WriterBabe: Patty Campbell, who writes a regular feature on YA books in THE

HORN BOOK.

WriterBabe: Welcome, Patty!

Shorecam: Nice to be here with you all.

WriterBabe: Would you like to make any opening remarks, or shall I hit you

with questions?

Shorecam: Shoot at will.

WriterBabe: Okay, first of all, please give us your definition of a YA book.

WriterBabe: What are the divisions in the genre?

WriterBabe: GA

Shorecam: Wow! Nothing like starting with a hard one! "What is a YA book" is

a question that us YA

WriterBabe: (That's my forte--dumbfounding the guest!)

Shorecam: aficionados argue about all the time. I guess I'd say that a YA

book, or novel, if we're tal

Shorecam: king about fiction here, is a novel told from the point of

view--AND WITH THE LIMITATIONS OF

Shorecam: PERCEPTION-- of a person between 12 and 17. GA

CGaley: (Nice description!)

WriterBabe: Ooh, I like that--with the limitations of perception!

WriterBabe: Makes a big difference.

WriterBabe: I'm interested in your quote, "A paradox that emerged was the

tendency of some librarians

Shorecam: Yes. A coming-of-age novel told from an adult remembrance isn't a

YA novel. GA

WriterBabe: and teachers to reject 'dark' or 'cutting edge' books...as 'too

adult' in content and theme,

WriterBabe: yet welcome adult books for YAs with open arms."

WriterBabe: How has that attitude changed, if at all?

WriterBabe: What's your take on that infamous word "edgy"? GA

Shorecam: Well, "edgy" is certainly better than "bleak," which is what a lot

of uninformed reporters

Shorecam: laid on YA lit last year. "Edgy" means real, risky, honest.GA

Mach2 2: lynwritebk

WriterBabe: Has the attitude toward these books changed, Patty? GA

Shorecam: Whose attitude? Librarians, teachers, parents, the general public?

Kids have always loved

Shorecam: dark stuff. GA

WriterBabe: Librarians and teachers, as per your quote. GA

Shorecam: Yes, as kids' world is riskier, they need books that reflect that

reality, and perceptive

Shorecam: youth advocates and publishers, too, recognize that. GA

WriterBabe: Thanks.

WriterBabe: Because of new electronic media, kids process information

differently, yes?

WriterBabe: How has that resulted in new book forms and styles? GA

Shorecam: Interesting question. Yes, there is this theory which has been put

forth by Eliza Dresang in

Shorecam: a book titled Radical Change. Eliza says that people, and

especially kids, have had changes

Shorecam: in the way the brain processes information because of exposure to

electronic media. Instead

Shorecam: of taking in information in a linear way, from A to Z, we gather

it in bits here and there

Shorecam: and put it together in our heads, interacting with it and each

other. So YA novels like

Shorecam: Monster are starting to reflect that.

Shorecam: GA

WriterBabe: Please tell us who Eliza Dresang is, Patty. GA

Shorecam: Oh, shoot. She's an academic, but I have to admit I don't remember

where. Blush.GA

WriterBabe: For those folks who haven't read MONSTER, it's written in the

form of a screenplay and also

WriterBabe: uses a variety of graphics.

WriterBabe: Do you want to add anything about MONSTER, Patty? GA

Shorecam: Yes, It also has passages which are Steve's thoughts about the

crime and the prison and the

Shorecam: trial. These appear in cursive on grey paper, while the screen

play

Shorecam: appears in print on white paper and the two are mixed together.

There are bits and hints of

Shorecam: the story, but you can put together at least 6 or 7 versions, all

contradictory GA

WriterBabe: We should add that it was written by Walter Dean Myers, a

fabulous writer.

Shorecam: And that it won the Printz Prize last year GA

WriterBabe: For my mailing about this chat, I quoted you.

WriterBabe: Since you made some of those remarks, a number of things have

changed in the book biz.

WriterBabe: Let's talk about some of those changes.

WriterBabe: For instance, what are the new forms of multiculturalism? GA

Shorecam: The way diversity appears in YA novels lately reflects the way it

is changing in our society

Shorecam: We're getting stories where the characters are of many different

ethnic and racial backgroun

Shorecam: ds, or characters that have diverse racial identities. The

relevant thing for writers is

Shorecam: that you no longer have to "be it to write it" with this new

perspective GA

WriterBabe: How are publishers responding to these manuscripts? GA

WriterBabe: Meaning, are they actively seeking them? GA

Shorecam: There have been a lot of these

Shorecam: (I'm struggling to know what to call them)

Shorecam: lately by writers who are not necessarily "multicultural." GA

WriterBabe: Interesting.

WriterBabe: Let's talk about religion. How is religion as taboo in YA's

changing?

WriterBabe: What changes would you still like to see? GA

Shorecam: Well, first I have to say that your short story collection, I

Believe in Water, is a prime

Shorecam: example of what I would like to see. That is, QUESTIONS of faith

raised from many

Shorecam: different perspectives, so kids can wrestle out their own

spiritual paths.GA

WriterBabe: Thanks, Patty. I love guests who plug my books. LOL

KellyMilnerH: (I BELIEVE IN WATER, the collection from HarperCollins EDITED

by WriterBabe.)

WriterBabe: Thanks, Kelly.

WriterBabe: So, Patty, you feel that things have changed re: religion? GA

Shorecam: Nope. I haven't seen any novels this year that touch on the

subject. GA

WriterBabe: Oh, dear.

WriterBabe: Still a taboo, then.

WriterBabe: GA

WriterBabe: A few more questions from me, and then let's open this to the

audience.

Shorecam: Maybe. But I do hear a lot of buzz among publishers, willingness

to acknowledge the need.

Shorecam: But it's very hard to find writers who are theologically literate,

and when this kind of thi

Shorecam: thing is bad, it's awful. GA

WriterBabe: You are a reviewer. Please tell us how books get reviewed. How

do they nominated for

WriterBabe: prizes, honor lists, awards? GA

Shorecam: Books get reviewed when their publishers send a copy to the review

journal. Same answer for

Shorecam: prizes, honor lists, etc. I can't review what I don't have in

hand, and honor committees

Shorecam: can't consider something they haven't seen. So writers need

Shorecam: to make very sure that the publisher is sending out those copies.

Now, how does a reviewer

Shorecam: choose which books to review--that's another question. GA

WriterBabe: But even when publishers send out the books, they don't all get

reviewed. That's been my

WriterBabe: experience.

WriterBabe: So, how DOES a reviewer choose which books to review?

Shorecam: Well, I have to tell you that my office where I am right now is

stacked with piles o' books

Shorecam: everywhere, and that's only the 2000 season. And I only do four

books a month for Amazon. So

Shorecam: I have to be highly selective. Mostly I choose what seems to me to

be

Shorecam: important, and let's face it, books I want to read. And of course,

authors I love. GA

WriterBabe: Last question from me, then it's time for audience

participation. So, folks, start typing ?

WriterBabe: and !

KellyMilnerH: ?

WriterBabe: You've said that you think the National Book Awards nominations

are peculiar this year.

WriterBabe: Why? GA

Shorecam: Aargh! Peculiar is right. In a year when we had fabulous books

like Dreamland, Gold Dust,

Shorecam: The Beet Fields, they chose three YA novels, one adult book, and

one who knows what. All of

Shorecam: them are very obscure except Book of the Lion, which really might

deserve the honor. GA

WriterBabe: Thanks, Patty.

WriterBabe: Now it's time for the audience to have its say.

WriterBabe: Kelly, you're first.

WriterBabe: (Type ? and !, folks)

KellyMilnerH: Sorry I jumped the gun. Two questions, actually. What makes a

writer "theologically"

KellyMilnerH: qualified? And how did you come to review for Amazon? GA

PHeeren: ?

Shorecam: Challenging question, Kelly. To me, "theologically literate" means

a writer who has an under

Shorecam: standing and some background on ---well--theology, in a broader

sense than one's own persona

Shorecam: lbelief structure. In other words, somebody who's put some effort

into studying this subject

Shorecam: Second question: Amazon asked me to be one of their two YA

reviewers, I guess, on the basis

Shorecam: of my twenty-six years of writing about YA books and being willing

to stick my neck out with

Shorecam: opinions. GA

WriterBabe: PH, your turn.

PHeeren: Did young adult fiction start out in the late 1960s, after the

changes of the counterculture

Shorecam: Waiting

PHeeren: of the late 60s or very early? I am confused since I have two

nieces, both teenagers

WriterBabe: (Queue's empty, folks. Type ? and !)

BOEDEN: ~ © ~ © ~ 15 MINUTE WARNING ~ © ~ © ~

PHeeren: ga

Chrizmoore: ?

BOEDEN: Lost Marilyn

CGaley: WOAH! Marilyn got bumped!

Shorecam: YA fiction as we know it began in 1967, with the publication of

The Outsiders. Before that

Shorecam: there was something called the "junior novel" that was mostly

about pimples and the junior

CGaley: (Ummm... Chrizmoore, you're next)

Shorecam: prom, and was not serious literature. I don't think the

counterculture

CGaley: (When I call on you)

Shorecam: had much to do with it though. (She says reluctantly) GA

PHeeren: oh, thanks for the history, shore

CGaley: Ok,Chriz... you're up... ga

Chrizmoore: Patty, are you familiar with Armageddon Summer by Jane Yolen &

Bruce Coville? If so, how

Chrizmoore: does that fit into your hopes for religion taboos in YA? GA

WriterBabe: Whew! Sorry about that. Computer crashed.

Shorecam: A worthy effort. Yolen and Coville resisted the temptation to

demonize the minister, and the

Shorecam: two characters didn't accept the spiritual positions of their

parents, but worked out their

Shorecam: own salvation with fear and trembling. GA

WriterBabe: (Queue's empty, folks)

Chrizmoore: They did a great job of thinking and writing comapssionately and

openly. Thanks Patty!

KellyMilnerH: ?

WriterBabe: Kelly, go ahead.

KellyMilnerH: Patty, there was a big discussion about GIVE A BOY A GUN on

the YALSA list.

KellyMilnerH: Did you agree that politics held this book about school

shootings back? GA

KellyMilnerH: (by Todd Strasser, BTW)

Shorecam: Held it back from what? GA

KellyMilnerH: Wider sales, more reviews, etc.

KellyMilnerH: GA

LYPHIS: ?

Shorecam: As far as I know it's doing just fine. I think the real problem

with the book is that it's

Shorecam: not very well written. GA

WriterBabe: Patty doesn't mince words!

WriterBabe: Phyllis, you're next.

LYPHIS: May I ask you to talk about the book “Cruddy.”

Shorecam: haven't seen it. Tell me more. GA

LYPHIS: Oh dear

LYPHIS: Forget the author

LYPHIS: My bookstore said there was a big stir by young people about it

MaryP2000: ?

LYPHIS: over a yr ago

LYPHIS: It was by an author, columnist, humorist

Shorecam: Interesting. I'll track it down. Are you sure it's YA? I'm really

ignorant about children's

Shorecam: books. GA

LYPHIS: I hadn't realized that and took it seriously

LYPHIS: yes, ya

LYPHIS: 16 yr old mc

LYPHIS: about a teen feeling, having lived a 'cruddy' life

WriterBabe: It's by Lynda Barry, according to Amazon.

LYPHIS: and who goes on to write about her coming suicide

LYPHIS: which she doesn't do, at the end...

KellyMilnerH: ?

Shorecam: Oh, of course. Lynda Barry. I think she's brilliant, but

definitely adult material for older

Shorecam: teens only. GA

WriterBabe: Mary, you're next.

MaryP2000: Patti, you said you had to be selective in choosing books to

review. Do you feel you are

BOEDEN: ~ º ~ º ~ 5 MINUTE WARNING ~ º ~ º ~

MaryP2000: influenced by the covers in making that decision when you are

facing those huge stacks?

Shorecam: Sure. GA

MaryP2000: GA

WriterBabe: Patty, care to elaborate? GA

MaryP2000: So it is only "favorite authors, publishers, etc.?

Shorecam: I'm not sure I can. Just an intriguing, gorgeous cover draws you

in. GA

Jgregers: ?

WriterBabe: Okay. Kelly, your turn.

KellyMilnerH: Who do you see as writers who should be read by WOULD-BE YA

authors? GA

Shorecam: No, of course not. Fresh, new writers definitely draw my interest.

GA

KellyMilnerH: NO, I'm asking what authors you consider the best of the best,

instructional for new writers

Shorecam: Start with Cormier, then go on to Cynthia Voigt, Chris Crutcher,

Walter Dean Myers, Norma

Julisari: ?

Shorecam: Fox Mazer, I could go on for hours. And responding to that thing

about

Shorecam: reviews, remember that VOYA magazine has an its goal to review

BOEDEN: ~~~~~~~~~~~~~Sorry, TIME IS UP FOR TONIGHT.

Shorecam: everyting YA, and Librarians buy from VOYA. GA

WriterBabe: Patty, any closing remarks?

WriterBabe: GA

Shorecam: You guys ask tough questions. But it's been fun. GA

WriterBabe: Thank you so much for being a great guest!

WriterBabe: Yeah, we're the toughies!

PHeeren: great chat, writer and boeden

WriterBabe: LOL

CGaley: Thanks Patty!

KellyMilnerH: Thanks Patty, fascinating stuff.

Julisari: Thank you, Patty!!!

</HTML>

Search This Blog

Strange Texts

Children's Writers Chat 11-14-00 Guest: Patty Campbell, reviewer/feature writer of YAs

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

WHAT THE WATCH TOWER BIBLE AND TRACT SOCIETY OF PENNSYLVANIA HAD TO SAY ABOUT WHAT WERE SUPPOSED TO HAVE HAPPENED in 1874

Uninterruptable Power Source (UPS) FAQ

1994 WORLD WIDE WEB FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS